1º - ID 0001000:

“Strong concept and viable realization in modular component that allows you to tailor the proposal to different physical and social contexts.” Marcelo Dantas

 

"The possibility to take each front module as a communication becomes a differentiating factor, in that it allows identifying and reveal the problem of its users, while being a plastic support for artistic expression and urban art.

both human and urban dimensions. Has a dimension that allows a person standing and lying down and allows an aesthetic integration into For a temporary shelter for a night this idea that allows to combineinclusive environment.” Ana Martins

 

“Undoubtedly a very compact structure, with the ability to go unnoticed in many urban situations. The fact that it can also be used as a billboard is itself an advantage, even better if it can be used to pass this important social messages to combat homelessness that is present in all our cities. I have some questions concerned the implementation of the proposal to be directly in contact with the ground.” Filipe Tabuada

 

“The project features a sensitive and positive deployment strategy that seeks to meet the existing communities of homeless.

Features an innovative design with dual function and configuration, being shelter and billboard, making it very compact architecture, even when combining in series other shelters. Apart from that the information framework, could potentially arouse active interaction with society.

The slogan - 'Half house - Full life' – offers a synthetic and clever idea around the theme of 'shelter', differentiating it from a 'House', which seeks to sensitize an enlarged audience, making it a better product perceptible and more user friendly.

The bidding of the project is clearly around a formal concept, the deconstruction of the archetypal 'House', defined by a light structure, with simple execution and low cost construction. Less defined were the spatial qualities experiences of the object proposed as well as the inclusion in the draft of a sustainability factor.” Tiago Mota

 

2º – ID 000760

“The demand for a presence and hybrid functionality, alternating between day and night, the public and the "private", open and closed, show a clear understanding of the dynamics of cities and their inhabitants ... homeless and housed. The solution gives credence by the intelligent use of new materials and technologies, which together allow us to imagine the success of its implementation in the public space.” Marcelo Dantas

 

“For a temporary shelter for a night, this idea, although not as inclusive as the first, also allows for a discreet way for those who use and benefit to those who pass, a space that allows a person to stand or lie down under their needs. Can adapt to various situations and how mobile it allows better management needs.” Ana Martins

 

“Also very compact, has the advantage that when closed, serve as an urban piece, a bank in a square or in a garden. I have some questions regarding the use of "Ecovative" due to its resistance to water and that it requires the same treatment as wood. In response to the tender modular criterion seems to me that it is well done.” Filipe Tabuada

“The project focus on implementation of the object in public and exposed spaces, and suggests a remarkable interaction between the community and the homeless population, through a bench, a wireless internet network, or the addition of a container for receiving of clothes and food.

Proposes a set of constructive reasons that stand out for their ecological and sustainable concern, in terms of energy and materials.

Features an innovative design, which privileges the existence of autonomous units, with 'intermitency' in its function of shelter, through an interesting transformation factor of the equipment, but constructively little consolidated.” Tiago Mota

 

3º – ID 000240

“The strategy of raising the modules from the ground proves to be relevant from a technical and functional perspective. This relevance is reinforced by the materiality and design, building an approximate presence of the chrysalis suspended in leaves and branches of trees. This relationship established with the public space,  almost symbiotic, reveals a remarkable scenic and poetic meaning in pursuit of raising the status of these citizens in the contemporary city, identifying what is expected to be a transition to something better.” Marcelo Dantas

 

“Excellent idea for a campaign that draws people's attention to the plight of the homeless. Gives visibility to the phenomenon and its functionality fits some necessary requirements, such as ensuring that the place where the person is homeless protects dry and where there between the water or bugs that may be on the floor.” Ana Martins

 

“Conceptually very clear. The fact that this type of structure / shelter to be raised off the ground is a big advantage because it avoids the obvious problems like water and dirt. Another advantage is the flexibility of your installation. The accessories were unnecessary.” Filipe Tabuada

 

“The project uses a very interesting and original scenographic concept, of a public lamp-shelter, but impractical for access and use, given the existence of a single point of suspension and the architectural profile of the piece.

The proposal presents a very reflected featured solution, for protection against rain and humidity due to its suspension, which substantially improves to quality and the comfort of living at the shelter. However, it is demanding in terms of installation prerequisites, due to the weight of the equipment. In the proposal was absent a stated requirement, the existence of a locker.” Tiago Mota